These posts are based on our Good Guy with a Gun calendar. (Do you have yours yet?) Today’s post is essentially the same as the calendar version.
It was raining just after 2 AM on a Thursday when a driver stopped for gas at a RoadDog station in Dayton. A man was hanging around the parking lot, and the driver did the kind thing: he let him sit in the car for a few minutes to get dry.
Then the man asked for a ride home. He didn’t have any gas money.
The two argued, and inside the car the man started assaulting the driver. The driver pulled out a gun and fired three rounds.
He went into the store and asked the clerk to call the police. On a 911 call, a man who said he was the shooter told dispatchers what had happened:
“Somebody just tried to rob me. I try to be nice and give him a ride.”
Police described an assault, not a robbery, but that’s what the caller said. The man he shot, 35-year-old Cedric Hughley, died at the scene. He wasn’t armed.
Dayton police Maj. Brian Johns noted that Ohio’s castle doctrine — no duty to retreat — covers a person’s vehicle as well as his home.
The driver cooperated with police and wasn’t arrested. The case was to go to the Montgomery County Prosecutor’s Office, which would decide on charges once all the evidence was in.
Johns had some advice for the rest of us:
“It’s 2 o’clock in the morning and the driver of the vehicle was being nice as far as allowing somebody to get in the car out of the rain. There’s a fine line you have to follow because we all want to be nice and help each other out but there’s also the common sense of where you’re at, the time of day.”
It’s an old joke: No good deed goes unpunished. But being armed just might keep that punishment from harming you.
Order your 2027 Good Guy with a Gun calendar today!
Sources
News
WDTN ran two articles, first on the shooting, then identifying the dead man.
1 dead after Dayton RoadDog shooting (Original incident)
Coroner identifies man dead after Dayton RoadDog shooting (Identification)
WHIO ran two articles, the first with an excerpt of the 911 call.
Fight over gas money leads to deadly shooting, police say (Original incident)
Coroner IDs man shot, killed after fight over gas money in Dayton (Identification)
Coroner identifies man killed in gas station shooting (WKEF / Dayton 24/7 Now)
Coroner IDs man who died after reportedly assaulting man over ride in Dayton (read as syndicated on Yahoo! from the Dayton Daily News, now a 404)
35-year-old Cedric Hughley killed in shooting after fight over gas money in Dayton (Channel2 NOW)
Driver Fatally Shoots Passenger at Dayton Gas Station After Ride Request Argument Escalates (US Update Herald)
2A / specialist media
Driver’s Act of Kindness at 2 A.M. Turns Into Attempted Robbery, Ends in Defensive Shooting in Dayton, OH (USA Carry)
OH: Dayton Gas Station, Driver Shoots Robbery Suspect 2 A.M. (Dean Weingarten, Gun Watch)
Defensive Gun Uses By People Legally Carrying Guns: 28 Cases During November 2024 (Crime Prevention Research Center)



I hate that it's become so risky to help people. It's hard to keep one's heart from becoming cold.