These posts are based on our Good Guy with a Gun calendar. (Do you have yours yet?) Today’s post is essentially the same as the calendar version.
I feel like I can’t emphasize it enough: Road rage is almost never worth it. But because so many people can’t get that through their heads, real self-defense cases are inevitable.
One Saturday afternoon, and a man driving by himself traded words with two people in another car: a woman at the wheel and a man riding with her. He drove past them, and they followed.
The solo driver tried to shake them. He pulled into Carle Foundation Hospital’s emergency department lot and back out onto Park Street, putting some distance between himself and the car behind him. It didn’t work. The chase ended on Park Street.
The two in the other car got out. The woman was holding a baseball bat, and the man started approaching — with his hand underneath his shirt, making the solo driver think he was armed.
The solo driver had a concealed-carry permit. He drew his gun and fired several rounds, hitting the passenger. Then he called 911.
The passenger went into surgery and was in intensive care that night. I can’t find a report of whether he really was armed, but, to be clear, I don’t think that would make a difference to the outcome.
The county’s state’s attorney, Julia Rietz, couldn’t get into the details of this specific incident when she spoke to a local station afterward, but she did walk through the law. She started with a caution for permit holders:
“There’s nothing about being a concealed carry card holder that gives a person a higher or different level of justification for using deadly force.”
Then the test itself:
“You’re justified in the use of deadly force in defense of yourself or another when you reasonably believe that such force is necessary to prevent imminent death or great bodily harm to yourself or another.”
No doubt.
Order your 2027 Good Guy with a Gun calendar today!
Sources
News
WCIA ran two articles, first on the shooting, then the state’s attorney on the law. I thought the legal discussion was a very good layman’s breakdown of things you should know, and it included the difference between a home invasion and a road rage shooting. Nice work by the local team.
One hospitalized after road rage incident in Urbana (Original incident)
Champaign Co. State’s Attorney breaks down legalities behind ‘use of force’ following 2 shootings (Legal discussion)
Man shot following road-rage incident in Urbana (The News-Gazette)
UPD: Road rage sends one man to the ICU after being shot (WAND; Wayback capture)
2A / specialist media
Dave Urbanski covered this incident at TheBlaze: Concealed-carrying motorist shoots male who approaches him allegedly with hand under shirt during road rage incident
Luke McCoy covered it at USA Carry: Concealed Carrier Shoots Man in Self-Defense After Attempting to Flee Road Rage Pursuers in Urbana, IL
Brandon Curtis covered it at Concealed Nation: Road Rage Turns Violent In Urbana: Concealed Carry Holder Fires In Defense
Illinois: Justified Self-Defense Shooting Leaves One Injured in Road Rage Incident (AmmoLand)



