These posts are based on our Good Guy with a Gun calendar. (Do you have yours yet?) Today’s post is somewhat updated from the calendar version.
A 48-year-old man arrived at his relative’s house — a 66-year-old woman — on a Monday evening. She was at home, and so was a man who had come onto the property unlawfully and stayed. And now he was making his way into the house.
Her relative had jumped through all the necessary hoops to acquire an Illinois FOID card and a concealed carry license, and he had a gun on him. He fired four times and hit the man.
Officers found both the invader and the homeowner inside with gunshot wounds. It’s not clear how she was hit; there’s no indication as to whether the invader was armed. Regardless, her wounds weren’t serious. His were fatal: He died at the hospital.
He was 35-year-old Anthony Beckley, and he was on Mandatory Supervised Release — parole — from the Illinois Department of Corrections, and so clearly had a record. Police couldn’t find any connection between him and the house.
Surveillance cameras at the house caught the altercation. The 911 calls were recorded as they happened.
A little over a week later, Macon County State’s Attorney Scott Rueter said he’d reviewed the police reports, the video, and the 911 recordings, and that no charges would be filed. He added a caution:
I would remind the public that although Illinois allows for defense of self, others, and in some instances, property, your actions in such a situation will be reviewed by agencies, prosecutors and possibly jurors with the view of 20/20 hindsight. I always advise that the best reaction, if possible, is to remove yourself and loved ones from the situation and summon law enforcement to do their job. Lives should not be squandered over mere property. I know also, such a course of action is not always possible, but where possible, it is the safest.
To me, that sounds like a prosecutor telling the general public not to get cocky: I think he’s willing to prosecute the hell out of people if he believes that they were just defending property.
That said, he’s not wrong: Getting yourself and your people out and letting the police handle it — assuming they arrive in a reasonable timeframe — in several ways beats having to pull the trigger.
And with that said, I’m not sure how Rueter’s comments apply to a younger man who is already invading the home of an older woman, or to her brother who happens upon the situation.
Sources
News
WCIA ran two articles, first on the shooting, then on the charging decision.
Man killed during attempted Decatur break-in (Original incident)
No charges being filed in deadly Decatur home invasion case (No charges)
The Decatur Tribune ran the police release and the State’s Attorney’s statement in full.
Decatur Police Respond to Shooting at Residence on E. Damon Avenue (Police release)
Macon County State’s Attorney Issues Statement on Review of Nov. 18th Fatal Shooting (State’s Attorney’s statement)
2A / specialist media
Decatur Home Invasion: 1 Dead, 1 Injured After Concealed Carry Defense (Concealed Nation)
The Armed Citizen® January 24, 2025 (America’s 1st Freedom)
The Armed Citizen® Feb. 14, 2025 (American Rifleman)




Yeah, he should have focused his statement on the situation at hand. A brief reminder of when it's not appropriate to use deadly force would have been fine, but not as the main point when discussing a man defending his elderly sister.