These posts are based on our Good Guy with a Gun calendar. (Do you have yours yet?) Today’s post is significantly updated from the calendar version.
Around 4 AM on a Thursday, 28-year-old Monte’l Porter-Robinson broke into the home of a woman he shared a child with. Then he shot her. She shot back. Both were wounded.
She called 911. Porter-Robinson died at the scene. The woman went to a hospital.
You now know essentially everything the news printed about the incident itself. Everything else is external.
Soapbox time.
There’s no time in reading those few lines to develop an attachment to the woman who saved herself. There are no details to let us know what she’s like, or what it was like to know Porter-Robinson. We don’t know their relationship. There’s a named villain, but we can’t see his face or hear his voice, and there’s no hero except “she.”
Humans don’t remember stories with no real characters and super-thin plots.
And so it is that a life-changing and life-ending event, a terrifying example of domestic violence that ended as a woman defended herself against a violent partner, is almost invisible to us.
People (Harold Hutchison from the Daily Caller, William Wallis as a guest on the Brown Duke Gun Show) ask me whether mainstream news sources fail to report defensive gun uses (DGUs). Maybe, but I’m not convinced. What matters the most is that in situations like this, there’s almost nothing available for them to report on, and even when we hear about them, we don’t remember them.
Off soapbox. Let’s get back to the externalities and aftermath of the incident.
Gunfire broke a second-story window of a home, and two rounds hit a car — one in the rear passenger door, one in a tire.
A local station interviewed Charlie Condon, a former South Carolina attorney general who wasn’t involved in the case. He started with where it happened:
If she’s in her own home and she’s shot, she certainly would have the ability to use self-defense.
He thought the woman’s own call counted for a lot:
She’s calling herself and self-reporting and nothing to hide. That also is really strong evidence. I’m sure that added to her credibility.
He also talked about how careful the police have to be about making arrests or definitively stating things early in the investigation:
They’re typically very cautious on making such a call because you’ve got someone who’s dead and someone who shot that person. So, you want to be very careful on making a call not to arrest anyone.
Pray for the child. At least he or she didn’t lose both parents.
Sources
News
WCIV ABC News 4 ran three articles, first on the shooting, then on the incident report, then on the coroner’s identification, plus a photo gallery.
Early-morning shooting in North Charleston leaves one dead, another hospitalized (Original incident)
North Charleston police investigating shooting that left one dead, one injured (Incident report; Charlie Condon interview)
Charleston County Coroner identifies suspect killed in Sablewood Street shooting (Coroner’s identification)
North Charleston police investigating shooting that left one dead, one injured (Photo gallery)
WCBD News 2 ran two articles, first on the shooting, then on the coroner’s identification.
Man dead, woman injured in Sablewood Street shooting (Original incident)
Coroner ID’s man killed by woman he shot on Sablewood Street (Coroner’s identification; also on Yahoo)
Charleston Co. Coroner IDs man shot by woman he shot first (Live 5 News)
28-Year-Old Man Identified as Victim in Sablewood Street Altercation (usupdateherald.blogspot.com)



